Natural unevenaged uea longleaf pine ecosystems exhibit a rich biodiversity. Seedtree and shelterwood regeneration methods 9 shelterwood. For more detailed silvicultural information related to a specific forest cover type or forest management treatment, readers are referred to the. In this paper, we compare the quality of trees subjected to uneven aged management, diameterlimit management, and no management. Fixed and equilibrium endpoint problems in unevenaged stand management abstract.
Silvicultural systems for managing home us forest service. Selection silviculture methods may create an unevenaged stand similar in structure to oldgrowth stands of longleaf pine, which are comprised of small, evenaged patches of trees. May 12, 2012 since wwii, forest management in fennoscandia has primarily been based on even aged stand management, clear cut harvesting and thinning from below. For example, uneven aged silviculture maintains an agestratified forest with ongoing dead wood production, while even aged silviculture breaks forest continuity, leading to long periods without large trees. The irregular shelterwood method is one way to begin shifting a stand toward unevenaged management over time. May 16, 20 however, there is little information on the longterm impacts of these two practices.
These commercial species grow in association with one another and are mixed with an additional 250 species. The basic requirement of regeneration methods resulting in unevenaged forests is the periodic harvest or natural death of a portion of the mature forest at regular intervals. In british columbia, uneven aged management has been limited, although interest is increasing. However, different forest management methods affect dead wood differently. Existing optimal rotation models include evenaged management exogenously into the model. Forest management, unevenaged silviculture, sprucefir. Difficulties in modeling unevenaged stands there are a numbers of reasons that modeling of growth and yield in unevenaged stands has not been as widespread as for evenaged stands in forest management. Optimizing unevenaged management of loblolly pine stands. Those methods were successful for regenerating stands, but, the unique longleaf ecosystem has not been fully restored by these approaches. In the evenage method, cutting is regulated by dividing the forest property. Although interest in uneven aged management is growing rapidly, our experience with, and scientific knowledge of, selection silviculture lags far behind that of even aged. The objective of this chapter is to provide an overview of these three studies and discuss. Evenaged timber management is a group of forest management practices employed to achieve a nearly coeval cohort group of forest trees. Unevenaged management of old growth sprucefir forests.
These habitat conditions occur where frequent fire keeps the forest in early successional stages. Efficacy of herbicide application methods used to control tanoak lithocarpus densiflorus in an unevenaged coast redwood management context article pdf available march 1996 with 24 reads. To find optimal transition harvests for irregular stands, either fixed end. Assuming volume maximization and natural regeneration, it is optimal to apply unevenaged management. However, there is little information on the longterm impacts of these two practices. Optimal structure and development of unevenaged norway. As an alternative, uneven aged management, based on selection cutting of individual trees or small groups of trees, has been proposed. Evenaged and unevenaged forest management are two common silvicultural systems used to produce. What is the effect of forest management on boreal forest biodiversity in fennoscandia and european russia at landscape level. We evaluated even and unevenaged silvicultural options for slash pine pinus elliottii engelm. Many alternative stocking control approaches have been developed for uneven aged stands.
Unevenaged management forest management florida forest. See also advantages of selection systems in appendix 2. Efficacy and associated factors of even and unevenaged management to promote oak regener. Forest stand dynamics stand development stages, disturbance dynamics, habitat 11.
Gamma diversity of forest management systems for 15 taxonomic groups in even. Electronic versions of publications may be downloaded, printed, and distributed. Unevenaged management options to promote forest resilience. Stocking control concepts in unevenaged silviculture oxford. To help alleviate this disparity, we developed nonlinear programming models of uneven aged loblolly pine and loblolly pinemixed hardwood management using the model of lin et al. This age structure is maintained through selection cuttings, in which trees can be removed individually single tree selection or as groups group selection e. The practice of even aged management is often pursued to minimize costs to loggers. Methods of measuring the growth of unevenaged forest stands have evolved from those developed in france and switzerland during the last century. Although interest in unevenaged management is growing rapidly, our experience with, and scientific knowledge of, selection silviculture lags far behind that of evenaged. The methods extend markov decision process mdp models in forestry e.
Unevenaged management a natural approach to timber. A test of groupselection and singletree selection cutting methods was installed in 80yearold evenaged oakhickory stands in the boston mountains of northern arkansas. The selection method is the only method used to regenerate unevenaged forests. Area control method of unevenaged management regeneration pct.
The details of applying the same method vary widely because they are altered for each species, forest region, and management objective. Optimal carbon storage in even and unevenaged forestry. Natural uneven aged uea longleaf pine ecosystems exhibit a rich biodiversity. The economics of unevenaged management has been studied since adams and ek 1974. Forest management strategy affects saproxylic beetle. The menominee, and salish and kootenai indigenous groups of north america have implemented successful frameworks of unevenaged forest management which predate european contact. Even aged timber management is a group of forest management practices employed to achieve a nearly coeval cohort group of forest trees. At the same time, uneven aged systems became increasingly popular in the northern rocky mountains and the pacific northwest for protecting visuals, for managing recreation sites, and for providing wildlife habitat. The objectives of this study were 1 to develop an original silviculture algorithm designed for uneven aged management and 2 to use it to assess the effects of the abovementioned management methods in longterm simulations.
May 12, 2012 an illustration of the two forest management systems to be compared in this study. Ckory stands in the boston mountains of arkansas david l. Recently, the most productive of these forests have been intensively managed by. As an alternative, unevenaged management, based on selection cutting of individual trees or small groups of trees, has been proposed. Management by the closetonature silviculture method had a positive impact on the forest characteristics. Stocking control refers to forest management operations that alter the number and arrangement of trees within a stand and is a central element of unevenaged silviculture. Furthermore, unevenaged growth and yield modeling has progressed rapidly since the first models were pioneered by. In contrast, unevenaged forest management creates stands with uneven tree age structure fig. Unevenaged management after a halfcentury of research on. The selection of trees to retain and remove is most commonly applied as part of the following treatments. Data were collected from a mature unthinned slash pine plantation in a flatwoods site in florida, and used to simulate six scenarios of even and uneven aged silvicultural regimes applied to slash pine stands, including a no.
More than 40 commercial hardwood species make up the southern hardwood forest. We evaluated even and uneven aged silvicultural options for slash pine pinus elliottii engelm. Assuming volume maximization and natural regeneration, it is optimal to apply uneven aged management. Uneven aged silviculture maintains a stratified forest with continuous cover and a stable microclimate by low level and more frequent harvesting. Because the amount of timber harvested per unit of surface in one entry is not the same for both approaches, for a same amount of timber harvested, the footprint in the forest that is left by the two systems. Managing forests for fish and wildlife only extensive stands of jack pine a firedependent species six to 20 feet tall with low ground cover. Pdf productivity and optimal management of the unevenaged. In some cases, the practices of even aged timber management are frequently implicated in biodiversity loss and other ecological damage. Pdf efficacy of herbicide application methods used to. Optimization is carried out by gradientbased, largescale interior point methods.
Many different methods exist for the management of. Pdf productivity and optimal management of the uneven. Forest regulation methods and silvicultural systems usda forest. The damage to retained trees can be very high also in regions with a longer tradition of unevenaged forest management nill et al. The basic requirement of regeneration methods resulting in uneven aged forests is the periodic harvest or natural death of a portion of the mature forest at regular intervals. Selecting and marking trees to retain and remove is a fundamental silvicultural practice frequently applied to the management of evenaged and unevenaged forest stands.
Evenaged and unevenaged forest management in boreal. Unevenaged management, on the other hand, is implemented by maintaining multiple three or more ageclasses through different kinds of selection cuttings, creating continuous tree cover in a stand at all times. Although longleaf pine has been mostly managed with evenaged methods and was formerly thought to be too intolerant for unevenaged silviculture croker and boyer 1975, recent evidence suggests this to be a viable management alternative. This publication provides information on the biological and operational tenets associated with sustaining unevenage forests to those interested in exploring unevenage management in southern hardwood stands. Three common and commercially important species are examined. Unevenaged forest management strategies of north american. Nov 30, 2010 unevenaged management a natural approach to timber. However, as discussed by getz and haight 1989 this approach, nor the frequently. Due to a dramatic decline by 97% in longleaf pine pinus palustris mill. Unevenaged management of oldgrowth sprucefir forests.
Maintaining trees of different age classes in the same area calls for more or less equal, periodic harvests under this practice, trees are removed on an individual basis to leave a desired number of trees in each size class. This pdf may have been generated by scanning the original printed publication. Diversity was quantified for hill numbers 0 d, 1 d and 2 d, which increasingly weight abundance of species, using sample size. The damage to retained trees can be very high also in regions with a longer tradition of uneven aged forest management nill et al. To slow down the decline of forest species diversity alternative management regimes have been taken into practice. Moreover, advanced regeneration is often cut to improve the visibility for machine operators during harvest procedures or damaged during skidding or forwarding operations newton and cole 2006. At the same time, unevenaged systems became increasingly popular in the northern rocky mountains and the pacific northwest for protecting visuals, for managing recreation sites, and for providing wildlife habitat. Although earlier research produced a substantial body of knowledge to guide evenaged management, less is known about application of unevenaged management methods in longleaf pine forests. Fixed and equilibrium endpoint problems in unevenaged.
Unevenaged silviculture as a management tool to mitigate. Many alternative stocking control approaches have been developed for unevenaged stands. The idea of coupling stand growth models with optimization engines for assessing tmrs in partial cutting silviculture uneven aged and thinning at cutting period has been frequently suggested in silviculture research gove and fairweather, 1992. Lack of concentration and research efforts in unevenaged management the philosophy of unevenaged management. The impacts of even aged and uneven aged forest management regimes will be compared to each other as well as to forest areas where no intervention has taken place to give a full picture of the impacts. Although longleaf pine has been mostly managed with even aged methods and was formerly thought to be too intolerant for uneven aged silviculture croker and boyer 1975, recent evidence suggests this to be a viable management alternative. At stand level, even aged management comprises a clear and repetitive cycle of distinct phases, including the regeneration, growing, and thinning, and final harvesting where typically a low number of live retention trees are leaf on the clear cuts. Chapter 8 bootstrap simulation, markov decision process.
Pb1798 unevenage management in mixed species, southern. To help alleviate this disparity, we developed nonlinear programming models of unevenaged loblolly pine and loblolly pinemixed hardwood management using the model of lin et al. Compared with the unevenaged methods singletree selection and group selection, clearcutting favored the red oak species over the white oak species. However, uneven aged management may be an objective for many reasons such as visuals, regeneration of shadetolerant species, health, soil, habitat, and fire protection. Data were collected from a mature unthinned slash pine plantation in a flatwoods site in florida, and used to simulate six scenarios of even and unevenaged silvicultural regimes applied to slash pine stands, including a no. Pdf evenaged and unevenaged forest management in boreal. Evenaged unevenaged harvest method clearcut, shelterwood,and seed. Productivity and optimal management of the unevenaged hardwood forests of hyrcania article pdf available in european journal of forest research 256 november 20 with 187 reads.
To create the balanced unevenaged distribution, harvest or natural death must be followed. Unevenaged stands provide continuous cover on a site, reducing problems with erosion and excessive runoff after heavy rains. Thus, unevenaged forest management can actually be regarded to consist of a range of methods, in which. Unevenaged management may be more compatible with many owners financial constraints. Marking of trees for harvesting must be highly controlled. Other methods for controlling stocking in unevenaged stands exist and many undoubtedly represent sound approaches to management. A test of groupselection and singletree selection cutting methods was installed in 80yearold even aged oakhickory stands in the boston mountains of northern arkansas. Provide examples of how to distill all the sustainable forestry considerations into an effective management prescription at the stand level. The idea of coupling stand growth models with optimization engines for assessing tmrs in partial cutting silviculture unevenaged and thinning at cutting period has been frequently suggested in silviculture research gove and fairweather, 1992. Pdf since wwii, forest management in fennoscandia has primarily been based. Unevenaged forest management strategies such as the ones practiced by these indigenous groups have been historically limited in north america due to a culture of evenaged forest management focused on. Unevenaged silviculture maintains a stratified forest with continuous cover and a stable microclimate by low level and more frequent harvesting. With timber prices down for many products, less interest in investing in costly regeneration after harvest, and greater interest in a more natural approach to forest management, many landowners are looking for alternatives to the traditional plant, thin and harvest approach of timber management. Retention forestry is usually similar to evenaged management, but some old trees, dead or living, or small stands of trees are retained in harvest to create structural diversity 14, 15.
United states department of unevenaged management of. Maintaining trees of different age classes in the same area calls for more or less equal, periodic harvests under this practice, trees are removed on an individual basis to leave a desired number. It has been suggested that uneven aged uea management techniques can meet multipleuse objectives including restoration of longleaf pine forests guldin 1996. The aim of this study was to determine if these management regimes improve tree and wood quality. While most models attempt to circumvent the dynamic complexities of optimizing unevenaged management, 1 haight 1985 and haight and getz 1987 specify and numerically compute a theoretically sound dynamic optimization model for unevenaged management. Thus, an unevenaged management system may socially or aesthetically beneficial than an evenaged management system. Since wwii, forest management in fennoscandia has primarily been based on evenaged stand management, clear cut harvesting and thinning from below. Stocking control refers to forest management operations that alter the number and arrangement of trees within a stand and is a central element of uneven aged silviculture. However, unevenaged management may be an objective for many. With discounted financial returns in the objective function and undiscounted criteria as constraints, such methods offer a means of computing the shadow price opportunity. In british columbia, unevenaged management has been limited, although interest is increasing. Economics of unevenaged management unevenaged management may be appropriate for certain class of ownership small private landowners some small landowners have a limited land base and wish to obtain periodic returns on investment especially if stand is already unevenaged or twoaged may be too costly to. Thus, unevenaged forest management can actually be regarded to consist of a range of methods, in which the forest.
Although earlier research produced a substantial body of knowledge to guide even aged management, less is known about application of uneven aged management methods in longleaf pine forests. Studies in unevenaged management have concentrated on the determina tion of optimal steadystate diameter distribution harvest policies for single and mixed species stands. Efficacy and associated factors of even and unevenaged. It has been suggested that unevenaged uea management techniques can meet multipleuse objectives including restoration of longleaf pine forests guldin 1996. Characteristics of evenaged and unevenaged harvest methods. Uneven aged regeneration selection method the selection method is the only method used to regenerate uneven aged forests. Unevenaged system group selection thinning single tree selection. This broader group of unevenaged management methods. What are the effects of evenaged and unevenaged forest. Unevenaged regeneration selection method the selection method is the only method used to regenerate unevenaged forests.
The papers are published in pdf format on the internet only. For example, unevenaged silviculture maintains an agestratified forest with ongoing dead wood production, while evenaged silviculture breaks forest continuity, leading to long periods without large trees. The diameter distribution of an oldgrowth longleaf pine forest is somewhat reverse jshaped, with trees ranging from 3 to 500 years old palik, mitchell, houseal. Both evenaged and unevenaged methods may employ different intensities and frequencies of harvests over time depending on rotation. Efficacy and associated factors of even and uneven aged management to promote oak regeneration in the missouri ozarks. The practice of evenaged management is often pursued to minimize costs to loggers.
Stocking control concepts in unevenaged silviculture. Unevenaged management is generally considered to be more difficult than evenaged management since all age classes are mixed together and therefore can be difficult to isolate and quantify. In this paper, we compare the quality of trees subjected to unevenaged management, diameterlimit management, and no management. Even and unevenaged forest management oklahoma forestry. Much of this information is yet in the developmental staage. Uneven aged management in 90 minutes silviculture background forest ecology management tools and stocking control multi aged management regime group selection example single tree selection example tools for assessment and management operations 2.
688 317 514 258 945 77 1518 1305 137 1428 215 931 100 906 177 1435 726 483 1057 1560 1354 823 95 273 169 1123 249 811 1164 480